Carver Bancorp Inc (CARV) QQ3 2025 Results Analysis: Revenue Decline and Profitability Pressures Amid Strong Liquidity and Investment Holdings
Executive Summary
Carver Bancorp Inc (CARV) reported QQ3 2025 results reflecting a material step-down in revenue and a pronounced swing to a quarterly net loss. Revenue for Q3 2025 was $7.68 million, down 30.16% year-over-year from $10.99 million in Q3 2024 and down approximately 26.24% quarter-over-quarter. Gross profit totaled $3.69 million (gross margin ~48.1%), but operating expenses rose to $9.34 million, driving an operating loss of $5.65 million and a net loss of $5.65 million for the quarter. EPS stood at -$1.09. The negative profitability is driven by a combination of lower top-line revenue, sustained high interest expense and other operating costs, offset by limited non-operating income in the period. On the balance sheet, CARV remains liquidity-strong with cash and short-term investments of around $94.1 million and a sizable long-term investments position (~$606.6 million), supporting total assets of approximately $727.5 million and net cash position (net debt of about -$2.1 million). Total liabilities of ~$695.3 million and stockholders’ equity of ~$32.3 million underscore a conservative leverage footprint relative to asset size, though tangible profitability remains weak.
From a strategic perspective, the company’s liquidity cushion and securities portfolio provide a platform to weather near-term headwinds, including macroeconomic uncertainty and rate volatility. However, sustained earnings weakness will be a focus for investors until CARV can stabilize/expand net interest income and curtail operating expenses. Management commentary (where available) and investor communications will be critical to assess the path to sustainability, including potential deposits growth, loan portfolio mix shifts, cost discipline, and any portfolio optimization actions tied to the investment book.
Key Performance Indicators
Revenue
7.68M
QoQ: -26.24% | YoY:-30.16%
Gross Profit
3.69M
48.09% margin
QoQ: -39.65% | YoY:-54.41%
Operating Income
-5.65M
QoQ: -167.30% | YoY:-29 826.32%
Net Income
-5.65M
QoQ: -167.30% | YoY:-29 826.32%
EPS
-1.09
QoQ: -165.85% | YoY:-36 433.33%
Revenue Trend
Margin Analysis
Key Insights
Total Assets: $727.5 million; Total Liabilities: $695.3 million; Total Stockholders’ Equity: $32.3 million.
Cash and Cash Equivalents: $49.96 million; Cash and Short-Term Investments: $94.08 million in aggregate liquidity buffers.
Long-Term Investments: $606.63 million; Total Investments: $650.75 million, indicating a securities-heavy asset mix.
Debt: Total Debt $47.82 million; Net Debt: -$2.14 million (net cash position). Debt to Capitalization: 0.597; Debt to Equity: 1.48.
Liquidity ratios are not provided in the data (current/quick/cash ratios appear to be near zero based on disclosed current liabilities), suggesting potential short-term liquidity sensitivities without the cushion of a strong working capital facility. However, cash and liquid investments mitigate near-term liquidity risk.
Financial Highlights
Revenue: $7.68 million in Q3 2025 (YoY -30.16%, QoQ -26.24%). Gross Profit: $3.69 million (YoY -54.41%, QoQ -39.65%). Operating Income: -$5.65 million (YoY deterioration; QoQ shift from positive/less negative to more negative depending on prior quarter mix). Net Income: -$5.65 million (YoY deterioration; QoQ similarly negative). EBITDA: -$5.45 million; EBITDARatio: -0.71; Net Income Margin: -1.49%. EPS: -$1.09 (Diluted -$1.09). Weighted Average Shares: 5.189 million.
Balance Sheet and liquidity indicators show a mixed picture:
- Total Assets: $727.5 million; Total Liabilities: $695.3 million; Total Stockholders’ Equity: $32.3 million.
- Cash and Cash Equivalents: $49.96 million; Cash and Short-Term Investments: $94.08 million in aggregate liquidity buffers.
- Long-Term Investments: $606.63 million; Total Investments: $650.75 million, indicating a securities-heavy asset mix.
- Debt: Total Debt $47.82 million; Net Debt: -$2.14 million (net cash position). Debt to Capitalization: 0.597; Debt to Equity: 1.48.
- Liquidity ratios are not provided in the data (current/quick/cash ratios appear to be near zero based on disclosed current liabilities), suggesting potential short-term liquidity sensitivities without the cushion of a strong working capital facility. However, cash and liquid investments mitigate near-term liquidity risk.
Valuation and profitability indicators vs. peers:
- Price-to-Book (P/B) for CARV: 0.296, well below many regional peers (e.g., FCAP 1.002; HBCP 0.906; OVLY 1.178; FNWB 0.584), signaling a sizable valuation discount that may reflect earnings risk, asset quality concerns, or market skepticism about near-term profitability.
- Price-to-Sales: 2.52; Price-to-Earnings (negative, hence not comparable): -0.42; Dividend yield: 0%.
- Four-quarter revenue run-rate around $39 million, with a recent peak in Q2 2025 at $10.41 million, suggesting a softer top-line trajectory in Q3 2025.
Note: The above metrics reflect reported figures in USD and should be interpreted in the context of a small regional bank with a securities-heavy balance sheet and negative earnings in QQ3 2025.
Income Statement
Metric
Value
YoY Change
QoQ Change
Revenue
7.68M
-30.16%
-26.24%
Gross Profit
3.69M
-54.41%
-39.65%
Operating Income
-5.65M
-29 826.32%
-167.30%
Net Income
-5.65M
-29 826.32%
-167.30%
EPS
-1.09
-36 433.33%
-165.85%
Key Financial Ratios
grossProfitMargin
100%
operatingProfitMargin
-149.1%
netProfitMargin
-149.1%
returnOnAssets
-0.78%
returnOnEquity
-17.5%
debtEquityRatio
1.48
operatingCashFlowPerShare
$-0.2
freeCashFlowPerShare
$-0.21
priceToBookRatio
0.3
priceEarningsRatio
-0.42
Net Income vs. Revenue
Expense Breakdown
Management Commentary
No earnings call transcript was provided in the data set for QQ3 2025. Consequently, there are no management quotes or theme-based quotes to extract for this quarter. The following section is based on the available financial reporting and standard expectations for this period.
N/A
— N/A
N/A
— N/A
Forward Guidance
There is no explicit forward guidance provided in the QQ3 2025 data set. Based on the results and the broader regional banking environment, guidance assumptions would likely hinge on: (1) stabilization or improvement in net interest income as rates move toward an optimal level for depositor yields and loan pricing; (2) continued optimization of the investment portfolio and potential impairment risk management given the securities-heavy balance sheet; (3) expense discipline to offset declining revenue; (4) potential deposit growth or balance sheet tailoring to support fee-based and core banking revenue. Our qualitative assessment suggests the achievability of any near-term guidance depends on the bank’s ability to stabilize NIM, manage credit costs, and realize efficiency gains. Key factors investors should monitor include: trajectory of net interest income, loan growth/composition (especially multifamily and commercial real estate exposure), allowance for credit losses and impairment charges, cost containment progress, and any changes to the asset mix that could impact liquidity and earnings stability.
Competitive Position
Company
Gross Margin
Operating Margin
Return on Equity
P/E Ratio
CARV Focus
48.09%
-1.49%
-17.50%
-42.30%
FFNW
1.00%
-12.30%
-0.38%
-85.10%
FNWB
1.00%
-25.10%
-1.23%
-11.87%
FCAP
95.80%
31.50%
2.48%
10.09%
FNWD
1.00%
2.68%
0.38%
56.21%
Gross Profit Margin
Operating Profit Margin
Return on Equity
P/E Ratio Comparison
Investment Outlook
Neutral-to-cautious. CARV demonstrates strong liquidity and a sizable investment portfolio that provide a cushion against near-term volatility. However, QQ3 2025 results show a pronounced profitability gap that must be closed to justify a higher multiple. The stock trades at a material discount to peers (P/B ~0.30), implying a risk-adjusted upside if management can stabilize earnings, improve net interest income, and achieve cost discipline. Investors should monitor: (1) trend in net interest income and NIM as rates evolve; (2) credit costs and loan portfolio quality; (3) efficiency improvements and overhead containment; (4) any changes in the investment portfolio impairments; (5) deposit dynamics and core funding growth. Given the current backdrop, a selective, near-term cautious stance is warranted until quarterly profitability shows sustained improvement.
Key Investment Factors
Growth Potential
Potential upside from deposit growth and stabilizing NIMs if interest rates move to a level that supports positive net interest income. Opportunities also exist in optimizing the investment portfolio and selectively growing higher-margin lending (e.g., multifamily CRE and SBA lending) while maintaining credit discipline. Valuation at a deep discount to peers (CARV P/B ~0.30) offers a potential upside if earnings stabilization occurs and capital adequacy remains solid.
Profitability Risk
Material earnings deterioration in QQ3 2025 raises concerns about sustained profitability. Risks include continued interest-rate volatility, credit losses in the loan portfolio, potential impairments in the investment book given market conditions, and regulatory/compliance costs. The securities-heavy asset mix could amplify mark-to-market volatility. With negative net income in QQ3 2025, market confidence in earnings durability is a key risk factor.
Financial Position
Liquidity buffers are strong on a nominal basis (cash + short-term investments ~$94.1m) against a securities-heavy balance sheet (long-term investments ~$606.6m). The bank carries modest leverage (Debt to Capitalization ~0.60; Debt to Equity ~1.48) and a net cash position, but equity remains relatively small (~$32.3m) with negative retained earnings. The core challenge is to translate the liquidity and balance sheet strength into sustained profitability.
SWOT Analysis
Strengths
Liquidity cushion supported by cash and short-term investments (~$94.1 million) and a large securities book (~$606.6 million long-term investments).
Balance sheet size (~$727.5 million in total assets) provides scale and capacity to absorb near-term earnings volatility.
Low leverage relative to asset base on a reported basis (Debt to capitalization ~0.60; Net debt slightly negative).
Established regional player with a NY presence and a diversified product set.
Weaknesses
Material quarterly net loss in QQ3 2025 (-$5.65 million) and negative operating income (-$5.65 million) with weak margins.
Very limited profitability despite sizable assets; negative earnings suppress ROE and investor confidence.
Securities-heavy balance sheet increases exposure to mark-to-market and ASC impairment risk; liquidity ratios are not explicitly favorable on a current basis.
Valuation at a deep discount to peers (P/B ~0.30) may reflect structural earnings concerns.
Opportunities
Potential NIM expansion and revenue stabilization if the rate environment supports improved loan pricing and deposit growth.
Portfolio optimization and risk discipline to improve credit costs and efficiency.
Operational improvements and digital enhancements to reduce non-interest expenses.
Opportunities to monetize or optimize the investment portfolio under favorable market conditions.
Threats
Sustained earnings weakness could pressure capital deployment and strategic options.
Market risk from the securities portfolio and potential impairments in rising rate or volatile markets.
Credit risk and concentration in specific loan segments (e.g., CRE/multifamily) amid rate shock.
Regulatory/compliance costs and macro headwinds in the regional banking space.
Carver Bancorp Inc (CARV) Q4 2025 Results — Revenue Decline with Net Loss; Balance Sheet Supports Ongoing Capital May Need; NYC Regional Bank Naviga...